Do you know of a restaurant that is on Fire Island? Let us know and we will add it! e-mail us
- Cherry's on the Bay
158 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove
Phone: (631) 597-7859
Cherry's on the Bay - Jumping Jacks Seafood Shack
140 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove
Phone: (631) 597-4174
- The Casino Cafe
On The Ocean
Phone: (631) 597-6150
Casino Cafe
- Kismet Inn & Marina
Oak Walk, Kismet
Phone: (631) 583-5592 - Le Dock
60 Walk Way, Kismet
Phone: (631) 583-5200 - Surf’s Out Restaurant
Bay Walk, Kismet
Phone: (631) 583-7400
Surk's Out Restaurant
- Flynn's Restaurant of Fire Island
1 Cayuga Street, Ocean Bay Park
Phone: (631) 583-5000
Flynn's Restaurant - Hurricane’s Bar and Grill Hotel and Resort
25 Cayuga Walk, Ocean Bay Park
Phone: (631) 583-8000 - Schooner Inn
57 Bay Walk
Ocean Bay Park
Phone: (631) 583-9561
Schooner Inn - The Inn Between
Ocean Bay Park
Phone: (631) 583-0111
- Albatross - Ocean Beach
Bayview and Denhoff
Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-5697 - Bocce Beach Restaurant
927 Evergreen Walk
Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-8100 - Castaway Bar & Grill
310 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-0330 - The Island Mermaid
370 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-8088
The Island Mermaid - Maguire's Bay Front Restaurant
1 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-8800 - Matthew's Seafood House
935 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-8016
Mathew's Seafood House - Rachel's Restaurant
324 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, Fire Island
Phone: (631) 583-5953 - Tequila Jacks
85 Compass Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
Phone: (631) 583-2628 - The Hideaway at Housers Hotel
781-85 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach
Phone: (631) 583-8900
- Bay Bar
Harbor Walk
Fire Island Pines
Phone: (631) 597-6010 - Blue Whale Restaurant
Harbor Pines Walk
Phone: (631) 597-6131 - Polo Restaurant
36 Fire Island Blvd., Fire Island Pines
Phone: (631) 597-8888
Do you know of a restaurant that is on Fire Island? Let us know and we will add it! Submit a Fire Island restaurant
- Fire Island
- Fire Island Restaurants
- Robert Moses State Park

